Off Broadway Review: Sulfur Bottom

The drama unfolds in a decaying family home on the outskirts of industrial sprawl, plagued by leaking factories and spanning over four decades.

It confronts environmental injustice and the legacies of trauma across generations of one embattled family, blending realism with surreal, symbolic elements such as talking animals and ghostly visitations.

As the family story unfolds, I found emotional and conceptual resonance. It served as a powerful analogy for climate anxiety, exploring the obligations we owe each other across generations.

Joyah Dominique’s performance as Melissa was a compelling portrayal, capturing her vibrant and humorous energy.

Kendyl Davis’s portrayal of Fran was equally impressive, showcasing her haunting yet grounded presence across multiple timelines.

Daniel Prosky’s evocative lived-in set design, Sam Weiser’s lighting to mark time, and Sid Diamond’s haunting soundscape create an immersive and layered emotional experience.

However, the structural clarity suffers behind the non-linear narrative and symbolic devices (deer, whale, ghosts) that I found distracting.

Sometimes, the story felt muddled or underdeveloped, leaving me with the impression that the early preview performance I attended was not fully realized.

While the absurd elements bolster the surrealism, they occasionally verge into the arbitrary. I would like to rewatch later performances as it felt more like a workshop draft, with earnest ideas overshadowed by narrative incoherence.

Despite these flaws, the play’s genre-blurring, time-slipping storytelling was at times gently revelatory and emotionally rich, rather than didactic. I appreciated Playwright Rishi Varma‘s subtle blend of humor, love, and despair.

Sulfur Bottom is a dreamlike and haunting production that delves into the environmental crisis and its impact on generations.

The characters are well-crafted and the staging is effective, but the lack of collective resistance undermines its environmental messaging.

The play is a poignant metaphor for climate trauma and the choices made by our ancestors. The performances are strong, particularly from Dominiqus and Davis, and the atmospheric staging and design enhance the emotional impact of the production.

However, the lack of narrative clarity sometimes feels like an abstraction. The absurdist elements, time jumps, and ghostly visitations occasionally feel disconnected, disrupting the flow of the story.

The absence of a unified response or broader movement leaves me wanting more. While it’s a great introduction to the subject of environmental justice, I felt it only scratched the surface.

As a part of Climate Week NYC, Sulfur Bottom has the potential to be a great opportunity to teach and learn about Climate Activism and Environmental Justice within context of Talk Backs and post-performance moderated discussions.  

Despite these flaws, Sulfur Bottom is a daring and emotionally resonant piece. It paints a haunting portrait of environmental devastation, family loyalty, and fractured legacies.

The blend of the mundane and the surreal invites deep reflection, especially in light of our growing climate anxiety.

If you’re drawn to bold theatrical storytelling, atmospheric staging, and performances that linger long after the curtain falls, this production offers much to explore.

On the other hand, if you prefer tighter plotting, more clarity, or a firmer narrative arc, some of the symbolic flourishes and tonal shifts might feel fragmentary or underdeveloped.

Ultimately, Sulfur Bottom is a memorable, if imperfect, exploration of what it means to be trapped in a place that may be killing you.

Playwright: Rishi Varma

Director: Megumi Nakamura

Venue: Jerry Orbach Theater at The Theater Center, New York

Running Time: Approximately 90 minutes, no intermission

Dates: Previews began August 13, opening August 20, closes October 11   

The post Off Broadway Review: Sulfur Bottom appeared first on The Good Men Project.

View the full article